[Dovecot] First release (v0.1.0) of the new Sieve implementation for Dovecot v1.2

[sergey ivanov]

Hi Stephan,
I've tried dovecot-sieve cmusieve with at the same place.
As I can see, both problems I've though to be in libsieve, actually
are that of dovecot.
Both plugins do not expand variables like %n, %h, %u.
But just filename works, - if I've set
---
sieve = sievescript
---
then both have used ~/sievescript file, like:
---
deliver(seriv): Oct 29 20:14:08 Info: sieve: using sieve path:
/home/seriv/sievescript
deliver(seriv): Oct 29 20:14:08 Info: sieve: opening script
/home/seriv/sievescript
deliver(seriv): Oct 29 20:14:08 Info: sieve: executing compiled script
/home/seriv/sievescript
---
Buth implementations don't work wihth slashes. I took a piece of sieve
script from working installation of dovecot-1.1.2 with Maildirs, and
here on dovecot-1.2-alpha3 I have default mail location with inbox as
mbox in /var/spool/log/mail/<user> and Maildir in
/home/<user>/Maildir.

I should test cmusieve before reporting these as libsieve bugs, I'm sorry.

-- 
  WBR,
   Sergey.

On Wed, Oct 29, 2008 at 3:31 PM, Stephan Bosch <stephan at rename-it.nl> wrote:
> sergey ivanov schreef:
>>
>> Hi Stephan,
>> Thank you for quick fix. I've built it (from changeset
>> 646:747107b816dc) and it looks like working with dovecot-1.2.
>> I'm doing some testing before put it into Sisyphus repository
>> (http://en.altlinux.org).
>> What I saw - it does not recognize lines like:
>> ---
>>  sieve = /var/sievescripts/%n/sieve
>> ---
>> as cmusieve did. But it works ok with default .dovecot.sieve files in
>> user home directories
>
> Hmm, I'll look into that. This is not intended and would be a bug.
>
>> Then, it reports
>> ---
>> error: failed to store into mailbox 'Inbox/R/Commits': Invalid mailbox
>> name.
>> ---
>> where cmusieve did
>> ---
>> fileinto fileinto "Inbox/R/Commits";
>> ---
>> this new plugin require changing slashes to dots:
>> ---
>> fileinto fileinto "Inbox.R.Commits";
>
> This doesn't look like something that has changed for the Sieve
> implementation specifically. Did you try dovecot-sieve-1.1 with dovecot 1.2
> to verify? I'll ask Timo about this. What is the configuration of your mail
> store. Did you perhaps migrate from mbox to maildir?
>
>> I think this changes should be described somewhere. May be, it's
>> already needed to create wiki page for libsieve at wiki.dovecot.org?
>
> Well, first one is probably a bug. The second one I am not sure about yet.
> I'll get back to you when I do.