[Dovecot] Issues with VANISHED CHANGEDSINCE

[Timo Sirainen]

On 6.11.2012, at 14.17, Timo Sirainen wrote:

> It would be possible to keep a separate expunge log which could remember the expunges longer. But that would be yet another different index file for Dovecot, which annoyingly complicates everything. And currently since it sounds like the only problem is activesync implementation using it, I'm not very interested in spending a lot of time on it.

Here's an idea how it could maybe be done without too much complexity:

Before deleting/replacing dovecot.index.log.2 file, scan all of the expunges from it and append them to dovecot.index.log.expunges file using the normal transaction log file format. Change the reader code to use it only when a special flag is enabled (because it has no other changes, it shouldn't normally be used). Use that flag when looking for old expunges. Once in a while recreate the file and drop some of the oldest expunges.

The annoying thing with that is that the file format wastes disk space. An alternative would be to write to the file using yet another format optimized for it, and then have a separate "expunge scanner" API that scans the expunge file and the transaction logs.

Anyway, not something I have time to implement myself anytime soon.