On 7.8.2013, at 9.29, Ulrich Zehl ulrich-dovecot@topfen.net wrote:
On Tue, Aug 06, 2013 at 09:20:13PM +0200, Thomas Leuxner wrote:
Now everything in between seems to create SMTPD rejections in some cases _or_ queue the mail and let it hit the quota in other cases. That's my whole point...
I'm sorry, I don't get your point.
Are you saying that quota-status does not eliminate all over-quota bounces?
That's to be expected. quota-status does not reserve quota when questioned, it only tells Postfix whether enough space is currently free or not. This is not free of race conditions, and therefore cannot eliminate all late bounces, even when quota-status has all the information, including size.
I think it would work also to do the check in SMTP RCPT TO stage and do quota bouncing only there. In LMTP/LDA stage use infinite quota to avoid bouncing. Yeah, user might get a little bit over quota (even over quota_grace) but not by much.