Hi,
enabling 'login_proxy_max_disconnect_delay' on IMAP proxy did the trick. I should have mentioned I use proxy servers, sorry
Thanks,
Dave
Dne 22.4.2017 v 06:25 Christian Balzer napsal(a):
Hello,
On Fri, 21 Apr 2017 10:43:47 +0200 dave@evilcigi.eu wrote:
Hi everyone,
I'm running dovecot with quite a lot of users and lots of active imap connections (like 20'000). I'm using different user IDs for users, so I need to have imap {service_count=1} - i.e. I have a lots of imap processes running.
We peaked out at 65k imap processes before upgrading to a version where imap-hibernate more or less works, but we're using a common ID.
dovecot 119157 0.1 0.0 59364 52216 ? S Apr01 48:25 dovecot/imap-hibernate [15137 connections]
The service_count parameter in this context is not doing what you think it does, I have it at 200 these days and that will allow imap (or pop3) processes to be recycled (they are labeled with "idling" when waiting for a new client), not having one imap process serve multiple clients.
mail 591307 0.0 0.0 29876 4712 ? S Apr20 0:00 dovecot/imap [idling] mail 735323 0.0 0.0 27396 4196 ? S 13:20 0:00 dovecot/pop3 [idling]
The advantage (for me at least) is that the dovecot master process doesn't have to to spin up a new mail processes each time during logins.
Since this process is quite single-threaded, it becomes a bottleneck eventually.
Everything works fine, until I reload dovecot configuration. When that happen, every client is forced to relogin in the same time and that causes a huge system load spike (2-3000 5 min load).
Unless you're making a change that affects the dovecot master process, restarting everything isn't needed and you should set "shutdown_clients = no". You could still kick users with "dovecot kick" at a leisurely pace, but security problems with the mail processes are rare.
I was thinking that it would be great, if dovecot wouldn't kick all the users in the same time during reload, but somehow gradually, during specified interval. I'm aware of the shutdown_clients directive that could help, but I don't like it - I've very much gotten to like it, once things got huge and busy.
I do want the clients get disconnected on dovecot shutdown and also I want them to relogin in reasonably short time after reload.
Is something like that possible with dovecot or does it make sense to implement that in the future versions?
Run a dovecot proxy (if you have single box with all these users on it, Mr. Murphy would like a word with you) and set "login_proxy_max_disconnect_delay" to something that suits you.
Christian