Re: Struggling with sieve, fileinto and variables.

Op 30-5-2018 om 14:01 schreef Barry Pearce:

Hi,

Im on Manjaro linux fully up to date running

dovecot 2.3.1-2
pigeonhole 0.5.1-2

All is running well except I am having problems with fileinto - it refuses to use variables, and mailboxexists is also failing for me.

Im just dealing with plus addressing - should be simple but the behaviour Im experiencing isnt right.

require ["variables", "envelope", "fileinto", "subaddress",
"mailbox"];
if envelope :matches :detail "to" "*" {
    set :lower "name" "${1}";
}
fileinto :create "folder3";

This works, but changing the last line to:

fileinto :create "${name}";

fails and files into inbox. As does:

fileinto :create "${1}";

It makes no difference if the fileinto is placed inside the if statement or otherwise. Using sieve-test suggests the basic scriptit should work and traces show the right action.

On a related matter the script Im actually trying to get to work is:

require ["variables", "envelope", "fileinto", "subaddress",
"mailbox"];

if envelope :matches :detail "to" "*" {
    set :lower "name" "${1}";
}
if mailboxexists "${name}" {
        fileinto :create "${name}";
}

But fails and files in the inbox.

This happens for a reason, which you can either find in your syslog or in the user log file (e.g. ~/.dovecot.sieve -> ~/.dovecot.sieve.log).

Modifying the script to:

require ["variables", "envelope", "fileinto", "subaddress",
"mailbox"];

if envelope :matches :detail "to" "*" {
    set :lower "name" "${1}";
}

if mailboxexists "${name}" {
        fileinto :create "folder7";
} else {
  fileinto :create "folder8";
}

Files into folder8. So the mailboxexists is failing.

     ## Started executing script 'plus-addressing' 3: envelope test 3:   starting :matches' match with i;ascii-casemap' comparator: 3:   getting to' part from message envelope   3:   extracting detail' part from address test+folder4@test.net 3:   matching value folder4'   3:     with key *' => 1 3:   finishing match with result: matched 3: jump if result is false 3:   not jumping 4: set command 7:   modify :lower "folder4" => "folder4" 7:   assign name' [0] = "folder4"   7: mailboxexists test   7:   mailbox folder4' cannot be opened 7:   some mailboxes are unavailable 7: jump if result is false 7:   jumping to line 9 10: fileinto action 10:   store message in mailbox `folder8' ## Finished executing script 'plus-addressing'

Here folder4 actually does exist - so the sieve-test confirms that issue.  Im at a loss as to whats going on. Im particularly perplexed by the difference in behaviour between sieve-test and the result under the live server.

You can also get a trace for the live server: https://wiki2.dovecot.org/Pigeonhole/Sieve/Configuration#Trace_Debugging

Regards,

Stephan.