oh wow - ignore my last message about sievec & environment. As the output says, it's just a warning... it is not blocking the compilation of the sieve script as I originally thought.

moving on: The compiled script is now being used as a sieve_before entry. The LDA is erroring on the result, something that I'll continue to investigate. The "failed to open" message below isn't correct - a trace shows the compiled .sieve being opened and read by the process; but I get that there is an error in interpreting & using the compiled script. The extdata .dict file is not opened by the deliver process.

I'm going to continue investigating. some info below if anyone's interested:

<script> require ["vacation", "variables", "vnd.dovecot.extdata"]; vacation :subject "${extdata.vacation_subject}" "${extdata.vacation_message}"; </script>

<compile script> # /usr/local/bin/sievec -P sieve_extdata /usr/local/etc/dovecot/sieve/before.sv /usr/local/etc/dovecot/sieve/before.sieve Warning: sieve: extdata: no dict uri specified, extension is unconfigured (sieve_extdata_dict_uri is not set).

# echo $? 0

<logs> 2010-01-12T08:41:08.005962+00:00 node001 dovecot: auth(default): ldap(test@domain1.test): user search: base=o=services scope=subtree filter=(uid=test@domain1.test) fields=homeDirectory,mailStoreDirectory,mailQuota 2010-01-12T08:41:08.006457+00:00 node001 dovecot: auth(default): ldap(test@domain1.test): result: homeDirectory(home)=/services/vmail/home/1000000 mailQuota(quota_rule)=maildir:storage=5M mailStoreDirectory(mail)=maildir:/services/vmail/mail/1000000/ 2010-01-12T08:41:08.006477+00:00 node001 dovecot: auth(default): master out: USER#0111#011test@domain1.test#011home=/services/vmail/home/1000000#011quota_rule=maildir:storage=5M#011mail=maildir:/services/vmail/mail/1000000/ 2010-01-12T08:41:08.012161+00:00 node001 dovecot: deliver(test@domain1.test): sieve: before: line 1: unexpected character(s) starting with 0xbe 2010-01-12T08:41:08.012556+00:00 node001 dovecot: deliver(test@domain1.test): sieve: before: line 1: unexpected unknown characters found at (the presumed) end of file 2010-01-12T08:41:08.012987+00:00 node001 dovecot: deliver(test@domain1.test): sieve: before: parse failed 2010-01-12T08:41:08.013380+00:00 node001 dovecot: deliver(test@domain1.test): sieve: failed to open script /usr/local/etc/dovecot/sieve/before.sieve 2010-01-12T08:41:08.860595+00:00 node001 dovecot: deliver(test@domain1.test): msgid=<20100112084107.2E72A27713@node001.netlog.net>: saved mail to INBOX </logs>

<dovecot config> plugin: sieve_plugin_dir: /usr/local/lib/dovecot/sieve sieve_plugins: sieve_extdata sieve_extdata_dict_uri: file:/usr/local/etc/dovecot/extdata.dict sieve_before: /usr/local/etc/dovecot/sieve/before.sieve quota: maildir sieve: ~/.dovecot.sieve sieve_dir: ~/sieve

$ cat /usr/local/etc/dovecot/extdata.dict priv/vacation_subject I am the subject. priv/vacation_message I ame the message. </config>

Cheers,

-Martin Foster

Le 12-Jan-10 16:25, Martin F. Foster a écrit :

I have the extdata plugin compiled, and am now trying to make a global sieve script to test it. I'm running into problems when using sievec to compile the script - I'm not getting the plugin's variables that are provided in dovecot.conf's plugin {}. I added a few sieve_sys_warning messages to track the calls to sieve_setting_get()

<output> /usr/local/bin/sievec -d -P sieve_extdata /usr/local/etc/dovecot/sieve/before.sv Warning: sieve: sieve_setting_get: req: 'sieve_max_script_size' res: '(null)' Warning: sieve: sieve_setting_get: req: 'sieve_max_actions' res: '(null)' Warning: sieve: sieve_setting_get: req: 'sieve_max_redirects' res: '(null)' Warning: sieve: sieve_setting_get: req: 'sieve_subaddress_sep' res: '(null)' Warning: sieve: sieve_setting_get: req: 'recipient_delimiter' res: '(null)' Warning: sieve: sieve_setting_get: req: 'sieve_plugin_dir' res: '(null)' Warning: sieve: sieve_setting_get: req: 'sieve_plugins' res: '(null)' Warning: sieve: sieve_setting_get: req: 'sieve_extdata_dict_uri' res: '(null)' Warning: sieve: extdata: no dict uri specified, extension is unconfigured (sieve_extdata_dict_uri is not set).

• Required extensions:

  0: vacation (9) 1: variables (17) 2: vnd.dovecot.extdata (29)

• Main program (block: 1):

00000000: EXTENSIONS [3]: 00000001: vacation 00000002: variables 00000003: SCOPE [0] (end: 00000008) 00000008: vnd.dovecot.extdata 00000009: VACATION 0000000a: (source line: 3) 0000000d: subject: VAR ${extdata.vacation_subject} 00000023: reason: VAR ${extdata.vacation_message} 00000038: handle: STR[77] "${extdata.vacation_message}${extdata.vacation_subject}<default-from><NO-MIME>"

00000088: [End of code] </output>

I'm new to dovecot's internals, it looks like it just needs some environment variables provided, but I'm puzzled as to how this is to be done. I've traced it through sievec.c -> sieve_tool_sieve_env -> sieve_tool_get_setting -> getenv() call.

More info: pigeonhole-sieve-extdata. I pulled+updated & rebuilt and confirmed

1. I've traced the process, there's no attempt to open or stat any dovecot.conf
2. using tip dovecot-1.2, dovecot-1.2-sieve,

the above behaviour just prior to sending this message. 3. The test scripts run because the test framework uses the test_config mechanism to provide sieve_extdata_dict_uri.

Any hints on how to get the dovecot.conf data to sievec?

Thanks,

-Martin Foster