I'm getting close - I believe I have one-way replication processing now. It's amazing watching the mails magically appear in the new server! I'll tender some updates to the wiki in the hopes it will help others.

At this time, I have two errors I haven't been able to eliminate with config changes:

dovecot: doveadm: Error: dsync-remote(user@mydomain.com): Warning: Transaction log file /var/mail/mydomain.com/user/sdbox/mailboxes/INBOX/dbox-Mails/dovecot.index.log was locked for 109 seconds (rotating while syncing) Mar 20 23:22:04 bubba dovecot: dsync-local(user@mydomain.com): Error: Remote command returned error 75: ssh -lvmail 192.168.0.4 doveadm dsync-server -uuser@mydomain.com

I don't know if the transaction lock issue will fix itself via repeated replication runs. But I have no idea what the "error 75" is.

Daniel

On 3/20/2017 10:05 PM, Daniel Miller wrote:

I have an existing server using mdbox & sis. There is a quantity of corruption - I have no idea where it came in. I'd had a previous rebuild some years ago and I thought I had a clean datastore. By "corruption" I mean missing attachments and either missing or mixed-up emails.

I've setup a new server on a virtual machine. Instead of copying the old configs I hand-adjusted individual settings using the current distribution example. The new server is running...but empty.

So now my intent is to migrate the mail to the new machine. A few items to note: the host's drive. This is via an exported NFS4 folder from the host,

1. The existing mail server is the virtual host. The mails are stored locally, in mdbox format, with sis enabled. And possibly zlib.
2. The new server, via VirtualBox, is presently configured for Maildir. I may change to sdbox - I'm now a little reserved about mdbox.
3. Instead of storing the mails within the virtual machine, I'm using

mounted on the guest, using the options: "auto,noatime,hard,intr,async,nordirplus". 4. My intent is to have the new virtual server become the primary mail server. The mail store will continue to be accessed by NFS4. No other servers or processes (besides backup) should access the mail store.

So...my question is what is the best method for the migration?

Reading the docs on Dovecot replication I'm still very unsure of how to implement it - particularly the "master-master" or "master-client" relationships. The docs are not 100% clear on which server gets which options. I can guess...which I'd really rather not do. But it seems to me getting one-way replication working would be the most "elegant" solution here.

Manual dsync is also an option - but again I'm not on which machine I should execute which options.

Imapsync is a possibility and the syntax is clear - but very slow in execution for 100k mails.

Any suggestions or pointers would be welcome.