Dear Dovecot experts,

I am in the process of planning migration from dovecot 2.3 to 2.4.1+dfsg1-6 on Debian Trixie, but userdb extra fields for quota_storage_size are ignored. All settings proved to work in 2.3; following per-user quota manual as outlined in [1].

Issue Cannot override setting quota_storage_size using userdb_quota_storage_size, but userdb_quota_storage_extra and userdb_quota_storage_percentage apparently work.

Setup Configures multiple userdb using driver passwd combined for a) user information and b) user-specific extra fields; auth. via passdb using driver pam defined in auth-system.conf.ext included by 10-auth.conf Excerpt from doveconf -n: … passdb system_pam { driver = pam } userdb userdb_01_passwd { driver = passwd result_internalfail = return-fail result_success = continue-ok } userdb userdb_02_quota { passwd_file_path = /etc/dovecot/quota-user-settings driver = passwd-file result_internalfail = return-fail result_success = continue } …

Excerpt from passwd file /etc/dovecot/quota-user-settings holding userdb extra fields: web1p1:::::::userdb_quota_storage_size=1200M

Default quota config excerpt from doveconf -n: … quota user { storage_grace = 100M storage_size = 750M quota_warning warn-95 { quota_storage_percentage = 95 execute quota-warning { args = 95 %{user} } } quota_warning warn-85 { quota_storage_percentage = 85 execute quota-warning { args = 85 %{user} } } } …

Result Userdb setting appear to work correctly as it combines both userdb files, see following output:

doveadm user web1p1

field value uid 644 gid 105 home /home/pop/web1p1 mail_path /home/pop/web1p1/mail system_groups_user web1p1 quota_storage_size 1200M

However, querying the quota only shows the default value, but not the user-specific setting.

doveadm quota get -u web1p1

Quota name Type Value Limit % user STORAGE 798830 768000 104 user MESSAGE 5617 - 0

Expected behaviour Any user should report default user quota (here 750M), but user web1p1 having user-specific setting for userdb_quota_storage_size=1200M should report a higher quota limit overriding the default quota setting.

I tried to specify user-specific values for userdb_quota_storage_extra and userdb_quota_storage_percentage, which worked; probably, because there were no default value specified in the config, yet? Setting userdb_quota_storage_extra to 200M works:

web1p1:::::::userdb_quota_storage_extra=200M

…

doveadm user web1p1

field value uid 644 gid 105 home /home/pop/web1p1 mail_path /home/pop/web1p1/mail system_groups_user web1p1 quota_storage_extra 200M

…

doveadm quota get -u web1p1

Quota name Type Value Limit % user STORAGE 798830 972800 82 user MESSAGE 5617 - 0

Quota is reported as correctly as 750M+200M=950M.

Same approach works when setting userdb_quota_storage_percentage, e.g. to a value above 100.

[1] https://doc.dovecot.org/main/core/plugins/quota.html#per-user-quota

Many thanks for your support!

Matthieu

Dear Dovecot experts, I am in the process of planning migration from dovecot 2.3 to 2.4.1+dfsg1-6 on Debian Trixie, but userdb extra fields for quota_storage_size are ignored. All settings proved to work in 2.3; following per-user quota manual as outlined in [1]. Issue Cannot override setting quota_storage_size using userdb_quota_storage_size, but userdb_quota_storage_extra and userdb_quota_storage_percentage apparently work. Setup Configures multiple userdb using driver passwd combined for a) user information and b) user-specific extra fields; auth. via passdb using driver pam defined in auth-system.conf.ext included by 10-auth.conf Excerpt from doveconf -n: ... passdb system_pam { driver = pam } userdb userdb_01_passwd { driver = passwd result_internalfail = return-fail result_success = continue-ok } userdb userdb_02_quota { passwd_file_path = /etc/dovecot/quota-user-settings driver = passwd-file result_internalfail = return-fail result_success = continue } ... Excerpt from passwd file /etc/dovecot/quota-user-settings holding userdb extra fields: web1p1:::::::userdb_quota_storage_size=1200M Default quota config excerpt from doveconf -n: ... quota user { storage_grace = 100M storage_size = 750M quota_warning warn-95 { quota_storage_percentage = 95 execute quota-warning { args = 95 %{user} } } quota_warning warn-85 { quota_storage_percentage = 85 execute quota-warning { args = 85 %{user} } } } ... Result Userdb setting appear to work correctly as it combines both userdb files, see following output:

doveadm user web1p1

field value uid 644 gid 105 home /home/pop/web1p1 mail_path /home/pop/web1p1/mail system_groups_user web1p1 quota_storage_size 1200M However, querying the quota only shows the default value, but not the user-specific setting.

doveadm quota get -u web1p1

Quota name Type Value Limit

                                                 %

user STORAGE 798830 768000

                                               104

user MESSAGE 5617 -

                                                 0

Expected behaviour Any user should report default user quota (here 750M), but user web1p1 having user-specific setting for userdb_quota_storage_size=1200M should report a higher quota limit overriding the default quota setting. I tried to specify user-specific values for userdb_quota_storage_extra and userdb_quota_storage_percentage, which worked; probably, because there were no default value specified in the config, yet? Setting userdb_quota_storage_extra to 200M works: web1p1:::::::userdb_quota_storage_extra=200M ...

doveadm user web1p1

field value uid 644 gid 105 home /home/pop/web1p1 mail_path /home/pop/web1p1/mail system_groups_user web1p1 quota_storage_extra 200M ...

doveadm quota get -u web1p1

Quota name Type Value Limit

                                                %

user STORAGE 798830 972800

                                               82

user MESSAGE 5617 -

                                                0

Quota is reported as correctly as 750M+200M=950M. Same approach works when setting userdb_quota_storage_percentage, e.g. to a value above 100. [1] [1]https://doc.dovecot.org/main/core/plugins/quota.html#per-user-quota Many thanks for your support! Matthieu

References

Visible links

1. https://doc.dovecot.org/main/core/plugins/quota.html#per-user-quota