Re: [Dovecot] Forcibly emptying a POP3 mailbox
Hello,
Thanks a lot, but the problem here are not the IMAP users accessing the server via squirrelmail. Few people use this.
What I mainly want to avoid are *POP3* users checking the „Leave a copy on the server” checkmark.
I need a way of automatically performing the DELE command at server level, just after a POP3 user *succesfully* downloaded his messages via POP3...
Thanks again, Răzvan
Am 04.02.2010 12:39, schrieb Răzvan Sandu:
Hello,
Thanks a lot, but the problem here are not the IMAP users accessing the server via squirrelmail. Few people use this.
What I mainly want to avoid are *POP3* users checking the „Leave a copy on the server” checkmark.
I need a way of automatically performing the DELE command at server level, just after a POP3 user *succesfully* downloaded his messages via POP3...
Thanks again, Răzvan
dont think this can be done, perhaps Timo knows magic what might be possible is to send additional warnings
http://wiki.dovecot.org/PostLoginScripting
whatever some scripting seems to me the only way to goal this
-- Best Regards
MfG Robert Schetterer
Germany/Munich/Bavaria
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1
On Thu, 4 Feb 2010, Răzvan Sandu wrote:
Thanks a lot, but the problem here are not the IMAP users accessing the server via squirrelmail. Few people use this.
Er, it doesn't matter if just few users use IMAP, but that the solution has to cope with it, did I misunderstood something?
What I mainly want to avoid are *POP3* users checking the „Leave a copy on the server” checkmark.
Yeah, did you've read the responses you got?
I need a way of automatically performing the DELE command at server level, just after a POP3 user *succesfully* downloaded his messages via POP3...
Well, I know that the client knows it has *successfully* downloaded messages, but how does the server know? Just to sent down some packets through the wire does not mean success.
The only logic I currently can think of is:
a plugin monitors POP sessions and deletes all messages the client does not download up to the newest one the client downloaded. One could argue, that the fact, that the client does not request message X, but message Y and arrivalOf(X) < arrivalOf(Y), implies, that X has been downloaded successfully already.
Because you do not seem to need such a high resultion, I think my idea with the postlogin script for IMAP users is a nice workaround, which also does not need much extra performance, esp. during user-access time. Moreover, because just few users use IMAP.
Regards,
Steffen Kaiser -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1.4.6 (GNU/Linux)
iQEVAwUBS2rHYb+Vh58GPL/cAQKzyQf+Nicmtl/NugGXw2QXLLyipX4Bduv41eBs iwViTHeEuflpk90K7iN5e4UEYVewbDRgoddGkb5Wdg0O93XggLvll7y9Lq2dvD72 jtDPjDw0+PSSY2lVMAnU/uWOW/ZwCSIXGRhzZicbWxf22ZBSpeBGXvNiPFCjMhKm hcR9uRxOeKmkKi8xGnw8flUltF3aa9gGKLa7ayuwQVF0vRW82DeaGmxDPbn0FWHa Jl+03scvDqOysjLplsYRLKBeWXvfEqvZtdxWnS5MBW2V+gipVjP/06HjeqjDJFhf Q7NwQLejEE1obq1bJHcqv+wI/T36nXI+DIReAayH3JG26MJcGnwX4w== =+Ya4 -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
Răzvan Sandu put forth on 2/4/2010 5:39 AM:
I need a way of automatically performing the DELE command at server level, just after a POP3 user *succesfully* downloaded his messages via POP3...
And this is going to really upset customers who access a single POP account from a work PC, a home desktop, and a laptop. Once you implement this, said users will download all the email onto, say, the work PC, and then not be able to access the emails from the laptop or home PC.
In my experience, the only (intelligent) users who "leave a copy on the server" are those with multiple computers and a provider who offers only POP, and not IMAP or webmail access to the mailbox.
Have you taken this into account?
-- Stan
Stan Hoeppner wrote:
In my experience, the only (intelligent) users who "leave a copy on the server" are those with multiple computers and a provider who offers only POP, and not IMAP or webmail access to the mailbox.
Agree - and they also usually have *one* of those computers set to delete the messages (I call it the 'master' when I'm setting this up for someone). This is how I have my old netzero account set up (the only account I have that doesn't offer IMAP).
--
Best regards,
Charles
participants (5)
-
Charles Marcus
-
Robert Schetterer
-
Răzvan Sandu
-
Stan Hoeppner
-
Steffen Kaiser