Hi!

I am using Unix groups to control access to shared mailboxes.

This works fine as long as files are not moved between mailboxes that are owned by different groups. The move operation doesn't change group ownership of the mail.

Is there a way to force dovecot to e.g. inherit the ownership from the parent folder, not only for new messages bot also for messages moved from one folder to another?

The wiki says: http://wiki2.dovecot.org/SharedMailboxes/Permissions -------------------- 8< -------------------- When mails are copied between Maildirs, it's usually done by hard linking. If the source and destination directory permissions are different, Dovecot create a new file and copies data the slow way so that it can assign the wanted destination permissions. The source and destination permission lookups are done only by looking at the mailbox root directories' permissions, not individual mail files. This may become a problem if the mail files' permissions aren't as Dovecot expects. -------------------- 8< --------------------

Does dovecot only look at the permissions or does it also take user/group ownership into account? The behavior I experience is that even though the mailbox directories are owned by different groups, dovecot doesn't copy the mails. (See my example below.)

Setting maildir_copy_with_hardlinks = no seems to fix the problem but maybe this behavior should be considered as a bug?

I am using dovecot 2.2.14 and maildir mailboxes.

Cheers, --leo

P.S.: Here is an example of the current behavior:

before the move from PAS to GSD: -------------------- 8< -------------------- GSD/.Eingang/cur/: total 0 drwxrws--- 2 nobody gsd 6 Oct 13 13:46 . drwxrws--- 5 nobody gsd 81 Oct 15 09:41 ..

PAS/.Eingang/cur/: total 4 drwxrws--- 2 nobody pas 89 Oct 15 09:39 . drwxrws--- 5 nobody pas 79 Oct 15 09:39 .. -rw-rw-r-- 1 nobody pas 4073 Jul 8 08:14 1404967500.M656935P20690.samba.intern.rk-klosterneuburg.at,S=4073,W=4213:2,S -------------------- 8< --------------------

after the move: -------------------- 8< -------------------- GSD/.Eingang/cur/: total 4 drwxrws--- 2 nobody gsd 87 Oct 15 09:42 . drwxrws--- 5 nobody gsd 81 Oct 15 09:42 .. -rw-rw-r-- 1 nobody pas 4073 Jul 8 08:14 1413358925.M22574P3008.samba.intern.rk-klosterneuburg.at,S=4073,W=4213:2,S

PAS/.Eingang/cur/: total 0 drwxrws--- 2 nobody pas 6 Oct 15 09:42 . drwxrws--- 5 nobody pas 79 Oct 15 09:42 .. -------------------- 8< --------------------

Mailbox directories are: -------------------- 8< -------------------- drwxrws--- 4 nobody pas 143 Nov 25 2013 PAS drwxrws--- 5 nobody pas 79 Oct 15 09:57 PAS/.Eingang drwxrws--- 10 nobody gsd 4096 Dec 11 2013 GSD drwxrws--- 5 nobody gsd 81 Oct 15 09:42 GSD/.Eingang -------------------- 8< --------------------

(In my own litte world, the mail should now be owned by the gsd group.. :-))

-- e-mail ::: Leo.Bergolth (at) wu.ac.at fax ::: +43-1-31336-906050 location ::: IT-Services | Vienna University of Economics | Austria