Re: [Dovecot] How to troubleshoot LDA or LMTP?
John Williams writes:
*What doesn't work* I thought the next step would be to execute dovecot-lda manually (as is suggested on the wiki and in numerous newsgroup posts), but I can't figure out how to do this. When I execute it as root and provide my non-root username via the -u option, it hangs. I can see that it spawns a child process that executes as the non-root user (specified with the -u option). So, could someone tell how to execute dovecot-lda manually please?
Maybe use "-d"?
I had no trouble invoking
dovecot-lda -c config-file -d user < mailfileIf it doesn't work for you, I suggest process tracing it.
Also, when does LMTP process messages? When sending mail via SMTP, or when reading mail via IMAP? I would prefer to use LMTP rather than LDA.
The former.
Joseph Tam <jtam.home@gmail.com>
Joseph Tam <jtam.home@gmail.com> writes:
John Williams writes:
*What doesn't work* I thought the next step would be to execute dovecot-lda manually (as is suggested on the wiki and in numerous newsgroup posts), but I can't figure out how to do this. When I execute it as root and provide my non-root username via the -u option, it hangs. I can see that it spawns a child process that executes as the non-root user (specified with the -u option). So, could someone tell how to execute dovecot-lda manually please?
Maybe use "-d"? D'oh! I meant -d. *hangs head in shame*
I had no trouble invoking
dovecot-lda -c config-file -d user < mailfile Aha! Piping a message to the process was the step I was not aware of. Thanks Joseph!
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1
On Tue, 6 Aug 2013, John Williams wrote:
dovecot-lda -c config-file -d user < mailfile Aha! Piping a message to the process was the step I was not aware of.
does offlineimap provides logs to get to know what mails are newly arriving to your local mail storage, in order to not filter the same message twice or re-filter messages, you've moved around manually?
Steffen Kaiser -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1.4.11 (GNU/Linux)
iQEVAwUBUgD3WF3r2wJMiz2NAQLsuggAk+leb2Hyc3F1B5A55gWd3GTuVmIzz2zH GXskHepwo3BgcdKTae6XY/XNP6tMRnG1UsLzq18HcvA8uCGzB3vKo1iM8fVPsHLV 0DDlYOxBUd8HRuCPB++AA41y66lppPUIqF1be1ILPJ56Jd6nEI2e/YB8vlOyagut 4WhsJK8Ruo+biDG++UFYZERFsI7xzvjawdtMGZto9lzYomZUP5Ig5DsXso28Y1by aRHOWzkMZYvNWGj3JDqxy4ePjzsM97QHKtOOmXNiDvyxwDQ3zMsUB+VBEjDq7z0k n491Hp9fCNyZ4SYtQhjSjeO6J4WKpcFxeaPdLvrB3JUH5moCNNDh9Q== =uBA2 -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
Steffen Kaiser <skdovecot@smail.inf.fh-brs.de> writes:
On Tue, 6 Aug 2013, John Williams wrote:
dovecot-lda -c config-file -d user < mailfile Aha! Piping a message to the process was the step I was not aware of.
does offlineimap provides logs to get to know what mails are newly arriving to your local mail storage, Yes.
in order to not filter the same message twice or re-filter messages, you've moved around manually? That is not a problem. The filtering process works perfectly when I manually invoke dovecot-lda. My problem is that I have followed the instructions here:
and here:
http://wiki2.dovecot.org/LDA/Sendmail
and here:
but neither dovecot-lda nor LMTP seem to be triggered whenever I send email from my MUA (Gnus). At least, I *think* I have followed the instructions correctly. Would you like me to post my dovecot config again, and the relevant portion of sendmail.cf?
Thank you very much for your help, I truly appreciate it.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1
On Thu, 8 Aug 2013, John Williams wrote:
in order to not filter the same message twice or re-filter messages, you've moved around manually? That is not a problem. The filtering process works perfectly when I manually invoke dovecot-lda. My problem is that I have followed the instructions here:
and here:
http://wiki2.dovecot.org/LDA/Sendmail
and here:
but neither dovecot-lda nor LMTP seem to be triggered whenever I send email from my MUA (Gnus). At least, I *think* I have followed the instructions correctly. Would you like me to post my dovecot config again, and the relevant portion of sendmail.cf?
Thank you very much for your help, I truly appreciate it.
As Stan already pointed out: a local delivery takes place only, when the mail arrives via a MTA. offlineimap synchronizes two IMAP folders, there is no local delivery at your side at all. Hence, neither LDA nor LMTP is invoked.
So I see two ways:
- keep offlineimap to resync your local store back to the server and keep both in-sync.
Then you can: 1a) run offlineimap to get new messages from the upstream server and sync current local messages. 1b) remove the new ones from the local store and feed them _manually_ to the LDA or LMTP. Now the filtering takes place and they are re-added to the mail storage. 1c) maybe: re-run the process until no new messages got downloaded, in order to keep the server in-sync
- no need for server messages in-sync with local message store
2a) setup a local MTA that accepts your domain and drops messages via Dovecot LDA or LMTP. Then get the new messages via fetchmail on a regular basis and hand the messages over to the local MTA.
2b) use fetchmail in combination with Dovecot LDA/LMTP. No local MTA necessary.
fetchmail will see only messages in INBOX as far as I know. So no filtering on the server must take place.
Steffen Kaiser -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1.4.11 (GNU/Linux)
iQEVAwUBUgNiqV3r2wJMiz2NAQISSAgAnSWnyf4kzNrbEd/+UcZGvmeegCWp4QY3 TWAIh8V8vbo+FyKyYomvRLt1mmq5CKJNwOUdz+A3u5R6XT25JZKxA5yYhUKlLNEU n05zIsmWvKV6DWahdTv7GL84kmyETqp7zYo5pBWRf9SqwGFH8+KcBGh1U3MTaKhQ QfzIj3eYk7a1DQld7u3ZaLSiKCBadWCakgNscY2mX+gzoN4EXt+X1zMO52uaZpJ3 QkJyd2AHrnpYgBbmr2maneYox3+67IyQChnzZ0t2c9uPodT4ukEkZFYjrucEGlfv JEUaOaVnuzx/Wi7gxSUL/agSiaksLaEkT/KMWS6wQMSI0NxUaGIHjQ== =f/Uy -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
Gnus supports IMAP natively, and even ManageSieve. Use that, don't run a proxy, it's a lot easier.
On Thu, Aug 8, 2013 at 4:19 AM, Steffen Kaiser <skdovecot@smail.inf.fh-brs.de> wrote:
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1
On Thu, 8 Aug 2013, John Williams wrote:
in order to not filter the same message twice or re-filter messages, you've moved around manually?
That is not a problem. The filtering process works perfectly when I manually invoke dovecot-lda. My problem is that I have followed the instructions here:
and here:
http://wiki2.dovecot.org/LDA/Sendmail
and here:
but neither dovecot-lda nor LMTP seem to be triggered whenever I send email from my MUA (Gnus). At least, I *think* I have followed the instructions correctly. Would you like me to post my dovecot config again, and the relevant portion of sendmail.cf?
Thank you very much for your help, I truly appreciate it.
As Stan already pointed out: a local delivery takes place only, when the mail arrives via a MTA. offlineimap synchronizes two IMAP folders, there is no local delivery at your side at all. Hence, neither LDA nor LMTP is invoked.
So I see two ways:
- keep offlineimap to resync your local store back to the server and keep both in-sync.
Then you can: 1a) run offlineimap to get new messages from the upstream server and sync current local messages. 1b) remove the new ones from the local store and feed them _manually_ to the LDA or LMTP. Now the filtering takes place and they are re-added to the mail storage. 1c) maybe: re-run the process until no new messages got downloaded, in order to keep the server in-sync
- no need for server messages in-sync with local message store
2a) setup a local MTA that accepts your domain and drops messages via Dovecot LDA or LMTP. Then get the new messages via fetchmail on a regular basis and hand the messages over to the local MTA.
2b) use fetchmail in combination with Dovecot LDA/LMTP. No local MTA necessary.
fetchmail will see only messages in INBOX as far as I know. So no filtering on the server must take place.
- -- Steffen Kaiser -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1.4.11 (GNU/Linux)
iQEVAwUBUgNiqV3r2wJMiz2NAQISSAgAnSWnyf4kzNrbEd/+UcZGvmeegCWp4QY3 TWAIh8V8vbo+FyKyYomvRLt1mmq5CKJNwOUdz+A3u5R6XT25JZKxA5yYhUKlLNEU n05zIsmWvKV6DWahdTv7GL84kmyETqp7zYo5pBWRf9SqwGFH8+KcBGh1U3MTaKhQ QfzIj3eYk7a1DQld7u3ZaLSiKCBadWCakgNscY2mX+gzoN4EXt+X1zMO52uaZpJ3 QkJyd2AHrnpYgBbmr2maneYox3+67IyQChnzZ0t2c9uPodT4ukEkZFYjrucEGlfv JEUaOaVnuzx/Wi7gxSUL/agSiaksLaEkT/KMWS6wQMSI0NxUaGIHjQ== =f/Uy -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
-- Sam Flint flintfam.org/~swflint
Sam Flint <harmonicnm7h@gmail.com> writes:
Gnus supports IMAP natively, and even ManageSieve. Use that, don't run a proxy, it's a lot easier. I know. I'm using dovecot because I'm getting mail from an extremely slow connection, so Gnus blocks the Emacs UI for several seconds, making Emacs unusable. Using a local server eliminates that problem.
On Thu, Aug 8, 2013 at 4:19 AM, Steffen Kaiser <skdovecot@smail.inf.fh-brs.de> wrote:
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1
On Thu, 8 Aug 2013, John Williams wrote:
in order to not filter the same message twice or re-filter messages, you've moved around manually?
That is not a problem. The filtering process works perfectly when I manually invoke dovecot-lda. My problem is that I have followed the instructions here:
and here:
http://wiki2.dovecot.org/LDA/Sendmail
and here:
but neither dovecot-lda nor LMTP seem to be triggered whenever I send email from my MUA (Gnus). At least, I *think* I have followed the instructions correctly. Would you like me to post my dovecot config again, and the relevant portion of sendmail.cf?
Thank you very much for your help, I truly appreciate it.
As Stan already pointed out: a local delivery takes place only, when the mail arrives via a MTA. offlineimap synchronizes two IMAP folders, there is no local delivery at your side at all. Hence, neither LDA nor LMTP is invoked.
So I see two ways:
- keep offlineimap to resync your local store back to the server and keep both in-sync.
Then you can: 1a) run offlineimap to get new messages from the upstream server and sync current local messages. 1b) remove the new ones from the local store and feed them _manually_ to the LDA or LMTP. Now the filtering takes place and they are re-added to the mail storage. 1c) maybe: re-run the process until no new messages got downloaded, in order to keep the server in-sync
- no need for server messages in-sync with local message store
2a) setup a local MTA that accepts your domain and drops messages via Dovecot LDA or LMTP. Then get the new messages via fetchmail on a regular basis and hand the messages over to the local MTA.
2b) use fetchmail in combination with Dovecot LDA/LMTP. No local MTA necessary.
fetchmail will see only messages in INBOX as far as I know. So no filtering on the server must take place.
- -- Steffen Kaiser -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1.4.11 (GNU/Linux)
iQEVAwUBUgNiqV3r2wJMiz2NAQISSAgAnSWnyf4kzNrbEd/+UcZGvmeegCWp4QY3 TWAIh8V8vbo+FyKyYomvRLt1mmq5CKJNwOUdz+A3u5R6XT25JZKxA5yYhUKlLNEU n05zIsmWvKV6DWahdTv7GL84kmyETqp7zYo5pBWRf9SqwGFH8+KcBGh1U3MTaKhQ QfzIj3eYk7a1DQld7u3ZaLSiKCBadWCakgNscY2mX+gzoN4EXt+X1zMO52uaZpJ3 QkJyd2AHrnpYgBbmr2maneYox3+67IyQChnzZ0t2c9uPodT4ukEkZFYjrucEGlfv JEUaOaVnuzx/Wi7gxSUL/agSiaksLaEkT/KMWS6wQMSI0NxUaGIHjQ== =f/Uy -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
-- Lecturer Department of Marketing University of Otago Dunedin, New Zealand
participants (4)
-
John Williams
-
Joseph Tam
-
Sam Flint
-
Steffen Kaiser