On Tue, Jan 13, 2009 at 8:00 PM, Timo Sirainen tss@iki.fi wrote:

On Wed, 2008-12-03 at 19:28 -0200, Allan Cassaro wrote:

...

I wrote a little patch to add the capability of the deliver to customize the "subject" of the rejection messages. Now is possibly to translate the body and subject!

I hate adding new settings to dovecot.conf, I'd instead just want to remove them. But I guess there's no choice here, especially because the current default subject is pretty bad (IMO). I applied your patch with some changes and also changed the default subject to the same as it currently is, so that there aren't any unexpected changes visible to others. http://hg.dovecot.org/dovecot-1.1/rev/410f0dcc1219

I'm thinking about changing the default for v1.2 to "Re: <original subject>". Or perhaps "Re: Rejected: <original subject>" or something like that. Does anyone have thoughts about those?

Humm... for non-english users, the "Re: <original subject>" it's ok, but it's not very "user friendly" about the problem... the (sender) user must open the e-mail to discover the problem, now image if the user have a PDA or cell phone with internet access (this is my case): The user will read the subject and thinking: "this is my response!", connect to internet (and pay for this) download some kbytes and discover that is a error, not a response... With the patch, I can translate the error to my languange and avoid this...

Sorry, but I like the way that the patch works...

Regards.

On 1/15/2009 9:20 AM, Charles Marcus wrote:

...

I'm thinking about changing the default for v1.2 to "Re: <original subject>". Or perhaps "Re: Rejected: <original subject>" or something like that. Does anyone have thoughts about those?

I would prefer something like:

Autoreply to: <original subject>

Nevermind... I thought 'Out of Office' autoreplies were being discussed...

For this, I would prefer:

REJECTED (see body for details): <original subject>

Although thats kind of long, so you could leave off the (see body for details)...

--

Best regards,

Charles

On Thu, Jan 15, 2009 at 12:21 PM, Steffen Kaiser skdovecot@smail.inf.fh-brs.de wrote:

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1

On Thu, 15 Jan 2009, Allan Cassaro wrote:

...

discover that is a error, not a response... With the patch, I can translate the error to my languange and avoid this...

Now consider this:

0. I assume you do not fluently speak Chinese

1. Somebody, who does, "translates the error to his language" and _you_ get the response.

I really hate the gibberish I get from MS Exchange translated into all the languages from all over the world and encoded into something like UTF7 without MIME.

Actually I don't know what's the most commonly understood term for "delivery failed" - maybe "ERROR:" - , but it should be plain English to avoid:

a) confusion for the rest of the world and b) problems you inherit in order to MIME-encode non-7bit characters in the header.

Bye,

Ok, I understood. But, this is a personal choice: translate or not to my language. Why exclude this choice? (l10n / i18n). Sorry, but this is a very requested feature from my users to me...

And now, for your consideration:

1. The general rule is: My users speak portuguese and send e-mails in portuguese;
2. The exception: **Some** users send e-mail in other languages (like Chinese) to some (and only to external) users...

Maybe, **some** (external) users will receive an error message that him will not understand. But 99,99999% of my (external AND internal) users will receive an error message that him will undestand.

So, why transform an "exception" in "general rule"? This not make sense to me. And why not give the mail adminstrator the choice?

On Thu, Jan 15, 2009 at 2:35 PM, Timo Sirainen tss@iki.fi wrote:

On Thu, 2009-01-15 at 14:19 -0200, Allan Cassaro wrote:

...

Ok, I understood. But, this is a personal choice: translate or not to my language. Why exclude this choice? (l10n / i18n). Sorry, but this is a very requested feature from my users to me...

The setting is already committed and will be in v1.1.9. I'm only talking about what the *default* value should be for v1.2.

For default I think the "Re: Rejected: <original subject>" is better. (The error is in subject not only in message body)

Thank you.

On 1/15/2009 12:16 PM, Charles Marcus wrote:

I still say it should be "REJECT: Re: <original subject>"...

Actually, that should be: "REJECT: <original subject>"

--

Best regards,

Charles

On 1/15/2009 12:44 PM, Timo Sirainen wrote:

...

Actually, that should be: "REJECT: <original subject>"

I don't like caps, but perhaps "Rejected: <original subject>" would be good.

Works for me... :)

--

Best regards,

Charles