Mail-crypt plugin clarification

Joseph Tam jtam.home at gmail.com
Fri Dec 15 02:29:09 EET 2017


Aki Tuomi writes:

> Dovecot does support making it difficult to prevent access to the stored
> mail.

Those who have had problems understanding the documentation might find
this unintended double-negative ironically funny.

> You can, with suitable workflows, ensure that the user's emails are not
> readable by anyone but the user.  Of course the only way to be fully
> sure is to use end-to-end encryption, ...

"Ensure" (or OP: "impossible") are very high standards of privacy.
If the OP really means it, then since a third party has control over
the (virtual or real) hardware, the server should never have access to
private keys or decrypted data.  (We're in agreement I think.)

If the OP lowers their standards to "inconvenient" to gain access,
then the plugin is enough.  It will keep the honest admin honest.

> ... like PGP or S/MIME, but this does go a long way to prevent admin access
> to user's email.

Don't ignore metadata; who/when/where (and headers?) could reveal much
information.

Joseph Tam <jtam.home at gmail.com>


More information about the dovecot mailing list