Rsync to backup dbox with SIS (Daniel Miller)

[ash-dovecot at comtek.co.uk]

> Probably not the answer you want - but I would strongly suggest using 
> Dovecot replication.? Dovecot replication Just Works - so don't reinvent 
> the wheel when Timo provided such a polished tool already.?
Okay, thanks, I'll look at replication for the warm spare. Although we
do use shared folders, which your link below says don't work properly.
> And based on 
> my previous SIS experience - while dbox is nice I would suggest avoiding 
> SIS until there are reports of more development.? Sdbox will be solid - 
> which is what you want for an archive - though maildir would be the 
> safest.? Archives don't need to be rapid-access - they need to be 
> dependable.? SIS is wonderful for space saving - but until there's more 
> safety checks built-in I'd suggest avoiding it for production backups.? 
> Drives are cheap - lost data, lost time, lost hair, lost sanity...is not.

Our main motivation for dbox is SIS. We don't have a very high volume of
mail, so maildir speed is unlikely to be an issue. What we do have is a
lot of users who like to mail around large files. Drives are cheap, but
there are advantages to a smaller mailstore. That said, data security wins.

We will probably abandon dbox entirely and continue with maildir, thanks.

> The backups don't have to be "visible" to other machines - don't even 
> have to be running IMAP/POP services (I think).? And the replication 
> command is run - via ssh (https://wiki.dovecot.org/Replication) - so 
> what's the problem?

Well, our backup servers are supposed to be running a minimalist set of
software. If we need to restore from backup after a security issue or
application bug on a production machine, then we are trying to minimise
the chance that the backup machine itself could be affected.

Anyway, if we aren't using SIS, then we needn't use dbox, and therefore
backup machines can continue to run a minimalist OS with only rsync.

Thanks,

Ash


---

To opt-in to receiving communications from us or to update your email preferences please go to https://lists.comtek.co.uk/prefs.
To be removed from receiving all communications from the Comtek Group, please unsubscribe at https://lists.comtek.co.uk/prefs and accept our apologies for any inconvenience caused.

The Comtek Group respects your privacy. Please find our privacy policy at http://www.comtek.co.uk/privacy-policy

This email and any attachments are confidential. If you are not the named recipient, please notify the sender immediately.
The unauthorised use, disclosure, copying or alteration of this message or its attachments is strictly prohibited.
Opinions expressed in this message are those of the individual and not Comtek Network Systems (UK) Ltd unless indicated by an authorised representative independent of this message.
Comtek Network Systems does not accept responsibility for any changes to this message after it has been sent.

Company Details: Comtek Network Systems (UK) Ltd.
Registered Office: Comtek Network Systems (UK) Ltd, Unit 108, Tenth Avenue (Zone 3), Deeside Industrial Park, Deeside, Flintshire, CH5 2UA.
Comtek Network Systems (UK) Ltd is a company registered in England and Wales with company number 05929974.