Hello,
This is not specifically a dovecot issue, but to it's antispam plugin, that being the case if private responses are deemed so please do so.
I've got a Postfix, amavisd-new, dovecot (delivery and sieve), setup with spamassassin. It's for the most part working fine, here's the problem, false positives and false negatives. The sieve moves spamassassin-tagged messages in to the Spam folder, sometimes it misses either a false positive or negative. What I'm wanting to do and this is where the dovecot-antispam plugin comes in is automatically retrain messages, a false positive or negative needs to be moved and reclassified accordingly. I've found a lot of google results indicating dspam, when I used this the results were terrible after three months of usage I gave up on it. I've thought about using spamc with dovecot-antispam to handle retraining or crm114, but not much on getting this going. If anyone has any information on this or any other non-dspam setup that would work I'd appreciate knowing about it.
Thanks. Dave.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1
On Sun, 25 Jan 2015, David Mehler wrote:
I've got a Postfix, amavisd-new, dovecot (delivery and sieve), setup with spamassassin. It's for the most part working fine, here's the problem, false positives and false negatives. The sieve moves spamassassin-tagged messages in to the Spam folder, sometimes it misses either a false positive or negative. What I'm wanting to do and this is where the dovecot-antispam plugin comes in is automatically retrain messages, a false positive or negative needs to be moved and reclassified accordingly. I've found a lot of google results indicating dspam, when I used this the results were terrible after three months of usage I gave up on it. I've thought about using spamc with dovecot-antispam to handle retraining or crm114, but not much on getting this going. If anyone has any information on this or any other non-dspam setup that would work I'd appreciate knowing about it.
What kind of information you are seeking? In what regards are the results of dspam _terrible_?
Installation / Configuration? :- http://wiki2.dovecot.org/Plugins/Antispam
Steffen Kaiser -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1
iQEVAwUBVMX0pnz1H7kL/d9rAQKDxQgAtPdGTRX3mbO/VQUQC2HIF0FlIt4197M5 agAKg6PhGnwOiQ7hxfm97JXQ6BICdgboZLmE1Tgz/EVPnv5joHY3zP6nJL1J+AQX H4elEeFB1Cw8zMgb/cYJ+kNt8tHlIISztLF6qzK8nvQeZHvNaE5o6y0rn6i7+8nn b7cVVJSebjia113CN0duRFNEJyNEkU9S94TsSFceQPAMyWlxBbpt7kakDOREznSU zjhC7BqDMtcZYy3K/lRSTPDFXickI2fmlal1C5oJFNuSqVjCtm7veh6uL9eBcPvw OYeyrPctnTFth/m1mzTqv0S3NKiswk5YqnR3C+5hJpNEmp/hanYE8w== =zEhj -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
Hi,
Can I get a look at your antispam configs? I'd like to compare them against mine.
Thanks. Dave.
On 1/26/15, Steffen Kaiser skdovecot@smail.inf.fh-brs.de wrote:
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1
On Sun, 25 Jan 2015, David Mehler wrote:
I've got a Postfix, amavisd-new, dovecot (delivery and sieve), setup with spamassassin. It's for the most part working fine, here's the problem, false positives and false negatives. The sieve moves spamassassin-tagged messages in to the Spam folder, sometimes it misses either a false positive or negative. What I'm wanting to do and this is where the dovecot-antispam plugin comes in is automatically retrain messages, a false positive or negative needs to be moved and reclassified accordingly. I've found a lot of google results indicating dspam, when I used this the results were terrible after three months of usage I gave up on it. I've thought about using spamc with dovecot-antispam to handle retraining or crm114, but not much on getting this going. If anyone has any information on this or any other non-dspam setup that would work I'd appreciate knowing about it.
What kind of information you are seeking? In what regards are the results of dspam _terrible_?
Installation / Configuration? :- http://wiki2.dovecot.org/Plugins/Antispam
Steffen Kaiser -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1
iQEVAwUBVMX0pnz1H7kL/d9rAQKDxQgAtPdGTRX3mbO/VQUQC2HIF0FlIt4197M5 agAKg6PhGnwOiQ7hxfm97JXQ6BICdgboZLmE1Tgz/EVPnv5joHY3zP6nJL1J+AQX H4elEeFB1Cw8zMgb/cYJ+kNt8tHlIISztLF6qzK8nvQeZHvNaE5o6y0rn6i7+8nn b7cVVJSebjia113CN0duRFNEJyNEkU9S94TsSFceQPAMyWlxBbpt7kakDOREznSU zjhC7BqDMtcZYy3K/lRSTPDFXickI2fmlal1C5oJFNuSqVjCtm7veh6uL9eBcPvw OYeyrPctnTFth/m1mzTqv0S3NKiswk5YqnR3C+5hJpNEmp/hanYE8w== =zEhj -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1
On Mon, 26 Jan 2015, David Mehler wrote:
Can I get a look at your antispam configs? I'd like to compare them against mine.
I use spool2dir in conjuntion with a custom inotify listener, that feeds the messages via socket to spamd, so it's highly unique. But post you config and what you want to achieve with it.
On 1/26/15, Steffen Kaiser skdovecot@smail.inf.fh-brs.de wrote:
On Sun, 25 Jan 2015, David Mehler wrote:
I've got a Postfix, amavisd-new, dovecot (delivery and sieve), setup with spamassassin. It's for the most part working fine, here's the problem, false positives and false negatives. The sieve moves spamassassin-tagged messages in to the Spam folder, sometimes it misses either a false positive or negative. What I'm wanting to do and this is where the dovecot-antispam plugin comes in is automatically retrain messages, a false positive or negative needs to be moved and reclassified accordingly. I've found a lot of google results indicating dspam, when I used this the results were terrible after three months of usage I gave up on it. I've thought about using spamc with dovecot-antispam to handle retraining or crm114, but not much on getting this going. If anyone has any information on this or any other non-dspam setup that would work I'd appreciate knowing about it.
What kind of information you are seeking? In what regards are the results of dspam _terrible_?
Installation / Configuration? :- http://wiki2.dovecot.org/Plugins/Antispam
Steffen Kaiser -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1
iQEVAwUBVMoKSnz1H7kL/d9rAQIJ4Af+IRhtUD36LBxJx7XpU7jM+U5VOxjkux0c f4ypPa6CJzpqQ60UBOpWT3EiME1dEnvw/y0U3V7rZPXFntXVAditynTDIiGsN97V OTB0Z7QCKq4AJ13kUoDNrCpAUaNhw5TzR2LwkEcAZSr9IE1aAWD1SbV8FFoxec2c p+L+wYA7FLgF/dZrmG1USjyqPyXT1ODOmESRwRZ5HJZ4io44nois5j3/psMLNwOE xqBy3dSz9uVBlGu4OeZEcWkd+2fWtf83bkyfb7ZM4zSgOe8qFE8YJ86HBq007PAN qPc6o6Q8uylkCZekNzKY3MF9AyI1XO0IsneC9/eLsGVpddu3oPxYhw== =y+NZ -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
participants (2)
-
David Mehler
-
Steffen Kaiser