I'm guessing that it is breaking my specific method of authentication.

Timo Sirainen wrote:

On Wed, 2006-06-28 at 07:32 -0700, Marc Perkel wrote:

...

Works great with all the beta versions. I installed RC1 and get massive authentication failures.

auth_debug_passwords = yes auth_master_user_separator=*

auth default_with_listener { mechanisms = plain

passdb passwd-file { # Master users that can log in as anyone args = /etc/dovecot.masterusers master = yes #pass =yes }

passdb passwd-file { # Path for passwd-file args = /etc/vmail/shadow.%d }

userdb passwd-file { # Path for passwd-file args = /etc/vmail/passwd.%d }

socket listen { master { path = /var/run/dovecot/auth-master mode = 0666 } }

}

dovecot: Jun 28 07:18:57 Info: auth(default): pam(mark@marxmail.net,64.81.213.137): pam_authenticate() failed: Authentication failure

It seems to be using wrong dovecot.conf file. Above there's no PAM configured, but here it's using PAM.

Right - hmmmmm - so why would it be using the wrong one? The one I want it to use is /etc/dovecot.conf. Is there another default?

OK - I just tried it again and here's what I got. Switching back to beta 9 fixes it so whatever you changed it started in rc1.

dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:52 Info: auth(default): passwd-file(tenacity@sturdywench.com,127.0.0.1): unknown user dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:54 Info: auth(default): client out: FAIL 9 user=tenacity@sturdywench.com dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:54 Info: auth(default): client in: AUTH 10 PLAIN service=IMAP secured lip=127.0.0.1 rip=127.0.0.1 resp=AHRlbmFjaXR5QHN0dXJkeXdlbmNoLmNvbQBsYWNleTEyMw== dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:54 Info: auth(default): pam(tenacity@sturdywench.com,127.0.0.1): pam_authenticate() failed: Authentication failure dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:54 Info: auth(default): passwd-file(tenacity@sturdywench.com,127.0.0.1): unknown user dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:54 Info: auth(default): client in: AUTH 11 PLAIN service=IMAP lip=69.50.231.8 rip=24.9.45.107 resp=AGxhcnJ5QGxlc3NpZy5vcmcAbDEzMDMwMGxc dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:54 Info: auth(default): pam(larry@lessig.org,24.9.45.107): pam_authenticate() failed: Authentication failure dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:54 Info: auth(default): passwd-file(larry@lessig.org,24.9.45.107): unknown user dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:56 Info: auth(default): client out: FAIL 10 user=tenacity@sturdywench.com dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:56 Info: auth(default): client out: FAIL 11 user=larry@lessig.org dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:56 Info: imap-login: Aborted login: user=<tenacity@sturdywench.com>, method=PLAIN, rip=127.0.0.1, lip=127.0.0.1, secured dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:57 Info: auth(default): client in: AUTH 12 PLAIN service=IMAP secured lip=127.0.0.1 rip=127.0.0.1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:57 Info: auth(default): client out: CONT 12 dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:57 Info: auth(default): client in: CONT 12 AG1hcmNAcGVya2VsLmNvbQBkYXJtMGs= dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:57 Info: auth(default): pam(marc@perkel.com,127.0.0.1): pam_authenticate() failed: Authentication failure dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:57 Info: auth(default): passwd-file(marc@perkel.com,127.0.0.1): unknown user dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:58 Info: auth(default): client out: FAIL 12 user=marc@perkel.com dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:58 Info: auth(default): client in: AUTH 13 PLAIN service=IMAP lip=69.50.231.8 rip=24.63.194.47 resp=AHBhdEBhbWJyeW5ldC5jb20AcjBzZWJ1ZA== dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:58 Info: auth(default): pam(pat@ambrynet.com,24.63.194.47): pam_authenticate() failed: Authentication failure dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:59 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.ambrynet.com: User pat has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:59 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.ambrynet.com: User admin has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:59 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.ambrynet.com: User notify has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:59 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.ambrynet.com: User dev has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:59 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.ambrynet.com: User donor has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:59 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.ambrynet.com: User ecomm has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:59 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.ambrynet.com: User gmail has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:59 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.ambrynet.com: User news has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:59 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.ambrynet.com: User shop has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:59 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.ambrynet.com: User travel has invalid UID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:59 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.ambrynet.com: User bank has invalid UID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:59 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.ambrynet.com: User adc has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:59 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.ambrynet.com: User avn has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:59 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.ambrynet.com: User comics has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:59 Info: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.ambrynet.com: Read 0 users dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:59 Info: auth(default): passwd-file(pat@ambrynet.com,24.63.194.47): unknown user dovecot: Jul 01 11:51:00 Info: auth(default): client out: FAIL 13 user=pat@ambrynet.com dovecot: Jul 01 11:51:01 Info: auth(default): client in: AUTH 5 PLAIN service=POP3 lip=69.50.231.8 rip=82.35.77.65 resp=AHBhdWxhQGljb21tb25zLm9yZwBkZWl0eTE= dovecot: Jul 01 11:51:01 Info: auth(default): pam(paula@icommons.org,82.35.77.65): pam_authenticate() failed: Authentication failure dovecot: Jul 01 11:51:01 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.icommons.org: User paula has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:51:01 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.icommons.org: User counsel has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:51:01 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.icommons.org: User mia has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:51:01 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.icommons.org: User info has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:51:01 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.icommons.org: User heather has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:51:01 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.icommons.org: User daniela has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:51:01 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.icommons.org: User registration has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:51:01 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.icommons.org: User keller has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:51:01 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.icommons.org: User pete has invalid GID -1 dovecot: Jul 01 11:51:01 Info: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.icommons.org: Read 0 users dovecot: Jul 01 11:51:01 Info: auth(default): passwd-file(paula@icommons.org,82.35.77.65): unknown user dovecot: Jul 01 11:51:02 Info: auth(default): client out: FAIL 5 user=paula@icommons.org dovecot: Jul 01 11:51:02 Info: pop3-login: Aborted login: user=<paula@icommons.org>, method=PLAIN, rip=82.35.77.65, lip=69.50.231.8

On Sat, 2006-07-01 at 22:21 +0300, Timo Sirainen wrote:

On Sat, 2006-07-01 at 11:57 -0700, Marc Perkel wrote:

...

OK - I just tried it again and here's what I got. Switching back to beta 9 fixes it so whatever you changed it started in rc1.

...

dovecot: Jul 01 11:50:59 Error: auth(default): passwd-file /etc/vmail/shadow.ambrynet.com: User pat has invalid GID -1

Well, I guess it's these. -1 really is invalid and I think it practically means that the process would get root's GID, which really isn't a good idea.

I'll add some extra checks to make sure this can't be done with other userdbs either..

Hmm. Actually with me it gives this:

dovecot: Jul 01 22:36:11 Fatal: setegid(4294967295) failed: Invalid argument

Also looking more closely your log it looks like you're not using those files as userdb either. So, fixed:

http://dovecot.org/list/dovecot-cvs/2006-July/006017.html

Just upgraded to RC2 and this problem is fixed. Good job!